The decision that led to the dispute
The dispute began in Orihuela Costa at a meeting on 12 November 2019. The association approved a ban by a qualified majority, and several companies owning flats challenged the decision. They argued that limiting an activity and banning it required different treatment.
What the Supreme Court decided
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the decision. It reiterated its full-court rulings of October 2024 that the power to restrict holiday rental activity includes banning it. For the decision examined, the required majority was three fifths of the owners representing three fifths of the ownership shares.
Why the dates and wording matter
The case concerns a 2019 decision and the legislation applicable at that time. The current Article 17.12 of Spain’s Horizontal Property Act expressly refers to approving, restricting, setting conditions on or prohibiting holiday rental activity by that double majority. It also states that these decisions have no retroactive effect. Assessing an individual case requires looking at the date and wording of the decision and the circumstances of the activity.
Is there a dispute in your building?
A dispute may arise when someone prepares a flat for holiday rentals and discovers an association decision affecting that use. We review the property’s circumstances and the association’s records to assess what the decision means for your case.
Judgment reference
Spanish Supreme Court, Civil Chamber. Judgment 1670/2026 of 29 October. Appeal 3393/2022. ECLI:ES:TS:2026:4404.

